BClayMoore

Sigh.

Thanks for the love, Chris. More on the possible future of Hawaiian Dick here:   http://bclaymoore.blogspot.com/2008/09/new-hawaiian-dick-model.html And thanks again to Josh and iFanboy for the podcast we did. I had countless people come up to me during con season looking to try the book (and other books) for the first time, citing our conversation as the movitation to seek me out...

HumphreyLee - I think you'd do well to listen to the podcast, and you'll see I don't label anything "uncritiquable." Essentially, you sum up one of my points with, "And any good reviewer out there is going to be able to at the least inflect a reasonable amount of either creative criticism, or just an understanding that whatever it is they're talking about may just not be a mate...

Josh- I'd be glad to discuss this on the show sometime. The discussion has been spun in so many directions in so many places that it's pointless to drag it out here. A few points, though: Uninformed criticism is completely useless. Criticism should have a purpose. Criticism is strictly opinion-based, and should be presented as such, particularly in comics, which has never been able to es...