Aug 6, 2008 > Final Crisis > #3 (OF 7)

Final Crisis #3 (OF 7)

Review by ultimatehoratio:

Final Crisis #3 (OF 7)

Written by Grant Morrison
Art and covers by J.G. Jones

Size: 40 Pages

Price: $3.99


674

pulls

Avg Rating: 4.2

Users who reviewed this comic:

Spoons lmiller31 TheNextChampion ultimatehoratio Tork Neb

Comments

it's nice to see a dissenting opinion amidst all the predictable gushing. how on earth you can threaten to drop a seven part story four issues in is beyond me though.

Posted by FACE on 08/06/08 at 10:34 PM

It's not fanfic if you're being paid to write the characters in an official capacity.  It is, by definition, fiction.  Nice try, though.

Posted by conor on 08/06/08 at 10:56 PM

I see your points and acknowledge that they are accurate.  Final Crisis is a hard sell to casual DC folks.  The good news is that this isn't necessary reading to appreciate the DCU at the moment.  Personally, I had fun, even though I scratched my head a bit.

Posted by Neb on 08/06/08 at 11:06 PM

Fiction can read like "glorified fanfic."  I made no inaccurate statement.  I'm just not as willing to give a free pass to everything Morrison does like some.  Nice try, though.

Posted by ultimatehoratio on 08/06/08 at 11:07 PM

@Face

If I quite after the next issue I can save myself $12 bucks which I can use to buy a trade or 3 drinks at Starbucks.  While I'm not giving Morrison a pass, I am cutting him some slack;  something in me believes it'll come together by next issue. 

Posted by ultimatehoratio on 08/06/08 at 11:22 PM

I'm sorry but your statement is innaccurate.  Being paid by DC means your story is not fan fiction.

Posted by conor on 08/06/08 at 11:32 PM

I'll make a quick edit to clarify!

Posted by ultimatehoratio on 08/07/08 at 12:14 AM

I'm just making a comparison.  If I were to say that Moon Knight #4 is 'dog shit,' I'm not saying that it is literally dog shit.  While FC may not technically be 'fanfic', it certainly feels like it.  Bless you if this is your thing, but this just wasn't for me, unfortunately.  I've certainly been willing to give it a chance!

Posted by ultimatehoratio on 08/07/08 at 12:39 AM

@Face-- I dropped Secret Invasion after 4.  If someone doesn't enjoy the story, they shouldn't shell out 4 bucks to a month to continue it. I liked it, but if he doesn't, he has no real reason to keep buying. 

Posted by Tork on 08/07/08 at 02:04 AM

@Conor: Begine semantics boy!

;)

Posted by JumpingJupiter on 08/07/08 at 02:46 AM

uhm, I meant begOne. :P I kid I kid.

Posted by JumpingJupiter on 08/07/08 at 02:46 AM

Login or Register to Add a Comment

® 2008 iFanboy