Jan 7, 2009 > X-Men Noir > #2 (OF 4)

X-Men Noir #2 (OF 4)

Review by sigridellis1:

X-Men Noir #2 (OF 4)

WRITER: FRED VAN LENTE
PENCILS: DENNIS CALERO
INKS: DENNIS CALERO
COLORED BY: DENNIS CALERO
LETTERED BY: NATE PIEKOS
COVER BY: DENNIS CALERO

Price: $3.99


Once again, this turns into a great little noir story. We have all the classic elements of noir -- the bad girl who can't see her way out, the weak-willed scion, the crime lords -- plural -- who manipulate everyone. The girl at the middle of it all who everyone wants and no-one understands. This is like Laura or The Big Sleep, it's like the meandering muddy darkness of The Long Goodbye. Everybody knows the score, yet nobody's wise. You don't need to know anything about the X-Men to enjoy the X Men. The X Men aren't superheroes in a noir world -- they don't have powers, as far as we can tell. Rogue is a mimic, but not a supernatural one. The X Men are noir characters in a noir world -- they are corrupt, they are cold, they are cynical. And some of these characters -- we don't know which ones, yet, will turn out to have hearts of gold. That's the way the genre works. This is a great, great book if you like noir.

Story: 5 - Excellent Art: 3 - Good

225

pulls

Avg Rating: 3.3

Users who reviewed this comic:

coltrane68 sigridellis1 USPUNX KreiderDesigns

Comments

This review made me want to buy the issues. Good review.

Posted by chlop on 01/08/09 at 05:25 PM

Great review, great issue.

I still haven't seen "Laura," I need to rectify that.

Posted by ohcaroline on 01/09/09 at 05:45 PM

@ohcaroline

You do need to rectify that - Laura is great. So is Gaslight (the Hitchcock version) - both are similarly creepy, suspenseful, and brilliantly acted.

Posted by coltrane68 on 01/11/09 at 07:49 PM

Login or Register to Add a Comment

® 2009 iFanboy