Invincible Iron Man #4
Review by mrmister:
WRITER: MATT FRACTION
PENCILS: SALVADOR LARROCA
COVER BY: GABRIELE DELL'OTTO
Price: $2.99
I think I have been too easy on the artwork in this book, and I guess I can attribute that to the fact that I enjoy reading it so much I don't stop to look for things that might bother me. Another part of it is that last issue many of the pages featured Tony in uniform, and these scenes are usually drawn and colored wonderfully. The same can not be said about this issue which has barely any panels of Iron-Man in action. Like many, I have problems with some of the faces Larroca draws, but I feel like that situation has progressed over these first four issues. In fact, his pencils on this issue are really solid although still not entirely consistent. My only complaint is with how young he made Reed Richards look; if Reed looks that young Johnny Storm must look like a toddler. Well then what is the problem that I've been glancing over? The coloring. To bring up just one example, why do characters particularly Tony sometimes seem to look like Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer? I suppose it is an attempt at hyper-realism but it just doesn't work in these panels and many others. As I said the pencil work is getting better, but for the artwork as a whole to really shine the coloring needs to find its groove. On to the story. Not too much to stay here, Fraction moves the story along nicely although slowly while staying true to the themes about Tony's fears that he has built up. Not bad by any stretch although easily the weakest of the four issues so far, but to be fair there is usually at least one slower one in six issue arcs.
370
pulls
Avg Rating: 4
Users who pulled this comic:
jmarquiso Grayghost razmy Ruo21 datalaughing ButchCassidy mrglass23 jspegele TacticalChaos15 the8thsignComments
I'm not the biggest fan of the pencil work either but for me as someone who normally doesn't care too much about art the coloring is a much bigger problem for the book. I think that you are certainly right about it being wonky at times and not entirely consistent, but compared to previous issues I still think it is improving especially considering this whole issue dealt with people not Iron-Man and tech stuff because obviously Larroca is much better at the latter than he is at the former. When the balance between those two is more even like I assume it will be in most issues I think/hope the art will improve even more.
Posted by mrmister on 08/07/08 at 08:02 AMI agree, the coloring is big problem. Everyone looks shrink wrapped.
Posted by JumpingJupiter on 08/08/08 at 03:38 AM



I can't say I agree with you on the pencils. The anatomy is wonky and the facial features erratically inconsistent. The layouts are pretty good and Larroca draws tech particularly nicely. Another thing that is puke-inducing is the photoshopping in of photographic elements - clouds, buildings etc. It sometimes works but more often than not it just looks dumb.
Posted by JumpingJupiter on 08/06/08 at 09:29 PMMatt Fraction is doing a great job! Otherwise this title would get dropped faster than hot coals.