Superman #678
Review by CharlesDaCriticCzar:
Written by James Robinson
Art by Renato Guedes and Jose Wilson Magalhaés
Cover by Alex Ross
Size: 32 Pages
Price: $2.99
Okay, I know James Robinson is...if you believe everything the ifanboy guys tell you...a writing god. Well if this issue was used as his legacy, he would be a fallen god. This issue was, dialogue wise, awful. I found myself saying out loud that, "That's not Lois" "That's not Lana"(we now that's her in the shadows...duhhhh). Everybody sounded like they couldn't string together coherent thoughts...now maybe some machine is emitting a wave that's making people speak with a stutter or maybe Mr. Mind is messing with everyone's mind and changing their 50+ years of character. For the love of god let the next issue be good like the first...which might have been good because there wasn't that much dialogue from characters that've been written before...I'm kinda not excited for another Justice League book under this guy, if he keeps handling large bits of dialogue this poorly. Can I get the next issue of Geoff Johns on Supes now.
330
pulls
Avg Rating: 3.4
Comments
Agreed. This wasn't the greatest issue of Superman, but I think he's just settling in. I'm confident this will be a top tier title in a few months.
Posted by Neb on 07/24/08 at 11:23 AM



I found the dialouge really confusing in this issue too.
Posted by Kimbo on 07/24/08 at 07:51 AM